We live in a world where people are born and die every day. Some live for more than a hundred years, some for only a decade or so, and some die as soon as they are born. Although human lifespans differ, each passes in the blink of an eye.
Where, then, does life come from, and where do we go after death? No one knows. Birth and death are therefore the great matter. It was for this great cause that the Buddha appeared in the world: to guide us out of confusion, show us where birth comes from and where death leads, and resolve this baffling riddle.
A person without wisdom does not know where life comes from or where death leads. Such a person neither cares about nor investigates the question, believing that coming into this world is simply a matter of eating, dressing, marrying, and having children, and thus muddles through an entire life.
Liang Qichao once asked, "What, ultimately, is the purpose of human life in this world?" Are you here merely to eat and dress? Is there so much food and clothing in the world, with no one to consume or wear it, that you were summoned here for that purpose? Clearly not. Are you here to marry, have children, and perpetuate the family line? If that were all, human life would be no more meaningful than the life of maggots in a cesspit. Clearly that is not the answer either.
What, then, is the purpose? The foolish neither know nor investigate. They come from a dream and return to a dream; confused and unawakened, they muddle through decades—even a hundred years—and let an entire lifetime pass.
Among human beings, those who seek the truth of life and the universe and attempt to solve the mystery of birth and death are indeed few.
Most people care only about gaining rank, making money, marrying, living more comfortably, and enjoying themselves. Satisfied with that, they never investigate the truth of life and the universe or the value of human existence. A person of wisdom refuses to remain bewildered and asks: Where do human beings come from? Where do we go after death? How did the universe arise? The search for correct answers gave rise to philosophy.
Many outstanding thinkers, ancient and modern, Eastern and Western, have investigated the origins of the world and human life. Yet despite exhausting their ingenuity and intellect, they have not reached a true and definitive answer. Some advocate idealism and others materialism; some monism and others dualism. But what is actually the case? No conclusive answer is found.
Only the Buddha can guide us out of confusion, solve the riddle, and correctly explain the origins of human life and the universe. To hear today this esoteric scripture containing the definitive Mahāyāna teaching is an unsurpassed blessing.
It cannot be compared with worldly good fortune—higher status, greater income, or a more comfortable life. However well you live, you cannot escape birth, aging, illness, and death; when the time comes, you depart naked and cannot take even a penny with you. Only by studying the Dharma, understanding this truth and the real nature of human existence, and thereby escaping the snare of birth and death do we receive the great blessing of the definitive teaching.
Many intelligent people, unable to find answers through academic study, turn to religion to see whether it can provide a true answer. Religions give different accounts of where human beings come from. Christianity says, "God created us," and Islam says, "Allah created us."
But if we inquire more deeply—if God created us all, who created God?—no answer is available. The Dharma alone explains the matter thoroughly: it is not a question of one being creating another. Buddhism teaches that Buddha-nature has existed since beginningless time ("beginningless" means without a beginning).
What is Buddha-nature? It is our capacity to see, hear, feel, and know. Through the six faculties—eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind—we encounter the six objects—form, sound, smell, taste, touch, and mental phenomena—and cognition arises when faculty and object meet.
Thus, the eye sees form, the ear hears sound, the nose smells fragrance and odour, the tongue tastes flavours, the body feels contact with the external environment, and the sixth consciousness, associated with the brain, cognizes and discriminates. Mind knows, body feels, eye sees, ear hears, nose smells, and tongue tastes: these capacities are our true nature.
Because people cannot see this nature, they assume it does not exist. Yet its functioning resembles electricity. When wires and a bulb are properly connected and the switch is turned on, the lamp lights, though the electricity itself remains unseen. The nerves of the brain are like the wires: they function by relying on this capacity.
If our breath stops—that is, if breathing ceases—the nerves of the brain are still there, but they can no longer function. So when Chan practitioners practice, they investigate: “Who is reciting the Buddha’s name?” Who, in the end, is doing the reciting? You are. But what do you call “you”? Do you call the body “you,” or do you call thought “you”?
The body is not you; it is only the house in which you live. Once Buddha-nature leaves the body, the body can no longer recite. Thought is not you either, for thought is the reflection of objective external conditions in the human brain; without those conditions, that thought would not arise.
If neither body nor thought is you, then who are you? Holding this critical phrase in the mind gives rise to a profound sense of questioning and cuts through deluded thought. When both perceiver and perceived fall away, awareness turns back upon itself and directly sees formless Buddha-nature. Although Buddha-nature has no form, it functions—it is present.
Thus, however thoroughly we investigate, the Dharma proves true, because its truth must be personally verified before it can bring genuine benefit.
When practice brings deluded thinking to an end—when the preceding thought has ceased and the next has not yet arisen—there is true emptiness: free of every attachment and unstained by a single speck of dust, yet clearly aware, not inert like wood or stone. What is this clear awareness? It is our capacity to know and perceive, our all-capable functioning; it is the Buddha-nature that everyone seeks to realize by seeing the true nature of mind.
This is the Buddha-nature that sees one’s nature! If we focus on it, awaken to it, and experience it, and can then train ourselves amid circumstances—not elated in favorable conditions, not troubled in adverse ones, and without clinging, love, anger, grasping, or rejecting toward circumstances—this is called “awakening.” The Buddha-dharma has a way to make us open this knot of confusion and see for ourselves the true nature of life and the universe, so the Buddha-dharma is the only correct guide to life.
Buddhism is nontheistic and differs from other religions. It does not teach that a God or deity created and governs us; rather, we govern and shape ourselves. Hence the saying, "Everything is created by mind." Other religions posit a supreme God or Lord who governs us.
Some who do not understand ask, "Does Buddhism not teach that after death the Ten Kings of Yama judge you? Does that not mean King Yama controls and sentences you?" No; that is a misunderstanding. In reality, we govern ourselves. Those who create wholesome karma receive wholesome results and go to favorable destinations;
Those who create evil karma must receive evil retribution and go to places of bitter suffering. It is not that King Yama assigns it to you. King Yama is equivalent to our public security bureau. If we have done nothing against the law, can the public security bureau interfere with us? If you commit a crime, the bureau will show you no mercy: it will arrest you and have you sentenced.
Everything is therefore governed by our own actions, not by someone else. Performing the ten wholesome actions leads to rebirth in the heavens, while evil committed through greed, anger, and ignorance leads to hell; both are one's own doing. The Ten Dharma Realms are a single mind.
They comprise the Four Noble Realms—Buddhas, bodhisattvas, pratyekabuddhas, and arhats—and the Six Ordinary Realms—devas, human beings, asuras, hell beings, hungry ghosts, and animals. All ten are created by our one mind.
The Buddhist teaching of karma and rebirth tells us to understand the law of cause and effect: as one sows, so shall one reap. If we fear the result, we must first refrain from creating the karmic cause. Ordinary beings do not fear creating causes; they fear only the results. Bodhisattvas fear only the causes: if they do not create a cause, they will not undergo its result.
If we break the law, for example, we create an unwholesome cause and will inevitably face prosecution, trial, and imprisonment. If we do no wrong, we will not suffer that result.
Ordinary people are not like this: they fear only receiving the result, not creating the cause. To achieve their enjoyment, they create evil karma by any means, and so society has many crimes. Hence the criminal law, civil law, and other legal sanctions.
In fact, it is precisely because people cling to this physical body as themselves that they want to enjoy to the fullest. This is especially so in the world today, with its flourishing science and abundant material goods and many pleasures, while people’s material desires run high and their craving is hard to fill: having this, they want that, all of it high-end consumption.
Without the income for it, they cannot help doing illegal things. So crimes in society keep multiplying, all because of this.
Because we mistakenly take this physical body to be ourselves, we create the cause for making karma and give rise to false feelings. Then, driven by these false feelings and views, we create karma as our feelings dictate, undergo retribution as our karma dictates, and revolve in birth and death with no end in sight. This shows that the Buddhist teaching of karmic cause and effect and rebirth is an irrefutable truth. Like the “law of causality” discovered by scientists, it is real, credible, and irrefutable.
The Buddhist teaching that "impermanence is swift" tells us that life is as brief as morning dew. A hundred years may appear to be a long life, yet it passes in the blink of an eye. We are now several decades old, but when we look back, the past seems to have happened only yesterday; decades have vanished in an instant. Time moves that quickly.
To the Buddha, our lives are like birth in the morning and death by evening. A hundred human years are only a moment to heavenly beings. In Tuṣita Heaven, one day is more than three hundred years in our world.
Can a person here live for four hundred years? Even if someone could, such a life would be extremely rare, yet to those beings it would amount to only a single day. Human life is short, and we will soon depart. What should we do? If we do not practice the Dharma diligently in order to free ourselves from birth and death, will we not have failed ourselves in making this journey through the world?
The Buddha's many admonitions sound an alarm, urging us to practice quickly and not waste this rare human life. We should therefore cease clinging to the physical body. It is not our true self but merely the house in which we live; the real person is Buddha-nature, the capacity to see, hear, feel, and know discussed above.
We must protect this capacity from being stained by adventitious defilements—the six objects of form, sound, smell, taste, touch, and mental phenomena. These defilements are called "guest dust": like dust, they are not the host and are therefore called guests. If we cling to them, seek enjoyment, and stop at nothing to satisfy our desires, we go astray.
Buddhism teaches us karma and rebirth and the swiftness of impermanence so that we may transform our lives, become genuine and morally sound human beings, and ultimately transcend the human state and attain Buddhahood.
Life does not last long. We must let go quickly, stop chasing external objects, and return to our original state—bare, unencumbered, clear, and pure—so that we do not suffer the cycle of birth and death in vain. At present, we are caught in inverted, deluded thinking without realizing it.
After attaining awakening upon seeing the morning star on the eighth day of the twelfth lunar month, the Buddha said, "Wonderful! Wonderful! All sentient beings possess the Tathāgata's wisdom and virtues." Why do they not see this for themselves? Because delusion, inversion, and attachment obscure their original nature. We are now immersed in delusion, inversion, and attachment. The Buddha's warning to let go of everything is like a sudden blow to the head, urging us to wake from the dream.
The course of human life is an unbroken succession of suffering: birth, aging, illness, and death are all suffering. We may have forgotten the suffering of birth. Newborn babies cry "Wah!"; none emerge laughing.
Why? In the womb they are warm, their skin is tender, and they have no contact with the external environment. As soon as they leave the womb, cold air strikes them with pain like needles.
In the womb the baby's head is originally upward; for birth, the head must turn downward, and the baby is squeezed through the mother's pelvis as though through a narrow gap between two great mountains. The child suffers and therefore emerges crying.
The child suffers, and so does the adult: mothers in the delivery room also cry out in terrible pain. Aging is suffering too. Vision dims; hearing fails; teeth fall out and can no longer chew. As the body ages and energy declines, one must depend on others for care and loses freedom and ease. Illness brings still greater suffering.
Everyone knows how agonizing even a minor toothache can be. As the saying goes, "A toothache is not an illness, but when it strikes it can cost you your life!" How much worse, then, are serious diseases? Cancer and similar illnesses can cause unbearable pain. I once saw a person with cancer rolling across the bed in agony; illness is therefore among life's greatest sufferings.
Death is more painful still. At death the four elements disperse, an agony compared to stripping the shell from a living turtle. The human body is formed by the gathering of the four elements—earth, water, fire, and wind. At death, the earth element dissolves first.
Its dissolution feels as though Mount Tai were pressing down on the body, leaving one so heavy and suffocated that family members cannot move one. The dissolution of water feels like being immersed in water, oppressively wet and uncomfortable. As fire dissolves, the whole body burns with fever and the cheekbones of the dying person turn bright red; this is a sign of fire's dissolution.
The dissolution of wind is still more painful, like a gale stripping away the surface of the earth layer by layer; the patient feels as though a knife were slicing away skin and flesh one layer at a time. As breathing fails, there is only exhalation and no inhalation, while deep phlegm blocks the throat and makes breathing impossible. When the phlegm finally subsides, the breath stops. It is extremely painful.
Thus birth, aging, illness, and death make the whole course of human life one of suffering. There are other sufferings as well—not obtaining what one seeks, separation from those one loves, and meeting those one hates—but we will not discuss them here.
Layman Sun Jingfeng said: "Some people study Buddhism solely because they fear birth and death. Others arouse the great aspiration to study Buddhism because they realize that all beings in the six paths were their parents in past lives and now sink in the sea of suffering, rising and falling without any prospect of escape.
They therefore follow the Mahāyāna teaching and its spirit of selflessness: contemplating impermanence, ending birth and death, further developing the Four Immeasurable, practicing the Six Perfections and myriad practices, walking the bodhisattva path, and aspiring that all beings attain Buddhahood." This passage explains that people arouse the resolve to study Buddhism for different reasons.
Some do so out of fear of birth and death: they know that death will be painful, do not know where they will go afterward, and turn to Buddhism in search of a destination. By practicing Pure Land Buddhism now, for example, they may aspire to rebirth in the Western Pure Land of Ultimate Bliss. Others arouse the aspiration in order to liberate sentient beings.
Buddhism therefore distinguishes five vehicles. The first is the vehicle of ordinary beings. Its followers know only to do good and avoid evil; they neither seek liberation from birth and death nor know how to attain it.
Many people, for example, burn incense and bow to the Buddha in temples on the first and fifteenth days of the lunar month, yet they do not truly understand the Dharma or know how to end birth and death. They have merely touched its fringe. This is called the vehicle of ordinary beings, or the human and deva vehicle.
The second is the arhat vehicle. Some practice solely to liberate themselves from birth and death. Knowing that birth and death are frightening and impermanence is swift, they resolve to practice in order to escape the six paths of rebirth as quickly as possible. This is the arhat vehicle.
The third is the pratyekabuddha, or solitary-realizer vehicle. Like arhats, its practitioners seek only their own liberation, but they are more perceptive: from subtle signs they discern larger truths, awakening to results through causes. They therefore cultivate the Twelve Links of Dependent Origination, unlike arhats, who cultivate the Four Noble Truths and investigate causes from their results.
In times when no Buddha appears in the world, pratyekabuddhas observe flowers blooming and fading, realize emptiness, suffering, and impermanence, and attain the path; hence they are considered slightly superior to arhats.
The fourth is the bodhisattva vehicle, whose practitioners resolve to cultivate in order to liberate sentient beings. Seeing that people everywhere suffer birth, aging, illness, and death, they first practice and liberate themselves so that they can then liberate others.
If someone falls into the Huangpu River, for example, how can you save that person if you cannot swim? You must first learn to swim and then learn lifesaving techniques. Swimming alone is not enough: when you try to save a drowning person, that person may cling to you so desperately that you cannot move.
The Six Perfections and myriad practices therefore teach the methods of liberating beings. First liberate yourself and then others: this is the bodhisattva vehicle. The fifth is the Buddha vehicle. It recognizes that all sentient beings possess undefiled wisdom-nature, no different from that of the Buddha—without distinction from Śākyamuni Buddha, Medicine Buddha, Amitābha Buddha, or any other Buddha.
Because of delusion and attachment, we mistake the physical body for the self and fail to recognize that this capacity for awareness is our dharmakaya. We should turn back without delay, let go of everything, restore our inherent wisdom and virtues, and perfect the fruit of Buddhahood. This is the Buddha vehicle. Although Buddhism distinguishes five vehicles, all are created by the one mind; the distinctions arise only because practitioners differ in the scope of their aspirations.
Buddhism teaches us that only the One True Dharma Realm—Buddha-nature—is real, while everything else is illusory and impermanent. The earth on which we live is no exception; it passes through the four intermediate aeons of formation, abiding, destruction, and emptiness. Each intermediate aeon comprises twenty small aeons.
At the end of a great aeon, the earth will be destroyed. Scientists also say that the earth will one day collide with another planet and be consumed by a great fire, while Buddhist scriptures likewise speak of the earth being destroyed by fire. We shall not discuss that here. In short, everything is impermanent and nothing can be grasped.
To study Buddhism is therefore to contemplate impermanence: we are taught to let go of everything and not to cling, for fundamentally nothing is lasting or real.
Even those who live for more than a hundred years pass away in what seems an instant, and such longevity is rare. Why, then, should we be so petty about sensual pleasures, material possessions, and personal gain, or refuse to forgive others? If someone happens to bump into us on a bus, for example, we may immediately start an argument. They did not do it deliberately, so we should not be so petty.
I once read a thought-provoking account in a newspaper. A sports reporter traveling abroad was walking too quickly and accidentally stepped on an elderly foreign man's foot.
The elderly man apologized to him instead: “I'm sorry. I was walking too slowly and got in your way. If I had walked faster, you would not have stepped on my foot.” The reporter blushed with shame. He had stepped on someone else, yet the other person apologized to him. What remarkable courtesy!
If we all possessed this spirit, society would be peaceful and disputes would not arise. Buddhism teaches us first to become decent human beings and then to rise still higher, transcending the ordinary. If everyone possessed noble character and was always willing to put others before themselves, society would be peaceful, the nation prosperous and strong, and wars would not occur.
Buddhism therefore benefits the whole world. We should constantly contemplate our own impermanence, remembering that we are merely guests in this world. The poet Li Bai wrote, “Heaven and earth are the inn of the myriad things; time is the passing traveler of a hundred generations.”
Heaven and earth are a vast inn in which we stay only briefly before departing. Why, then, should we behave discourteously, cling so tightly, or fail to treat others generously? To study Buddhism is to put others before oneself and eliminate attachment, greed, anger, ignorance, pride, and doubt; only then can we attain the Way.
Greed arises because we mistakenly take the physical body to be the self and consequently seek pleasure and long life.
After becoming emperor, Qin Shi Huang wished to live forever and enjoy imperial power without end, so he sent people in search of an elixir of immortality. This was a manifestation of greed. The unrest of present-day society and the prevalence of corruption and bribery are likewise driven by greed. If we awaken to the fact that everything is illusory and unobtainable, what remains to be greedy for? We should instead do all we can for the welfare of the public and accumulate virtue.
As the saying goes, “Better than leaving ten thousand pieces of gold to one's children is toaccumulate virtue and bequeath them a classic.” It warns us that leaving money to our descendants is less beneficial than teaching them to do good and accumulate virtue. Once we understand that everything is illusory and impermanent, we cease grasping and clinging. Without clinging, we let go; when we let go, the mind becomes empty; when the mind is empty, our true nature manifests and we transcend birth and death.
The principle is simple and easy to understand, but not so easy to put into practice, because the habit of attachment is deeply rooted. Even when told to let go, we cannot do so. We must therefore train at every moment and struggle with our own habits until this old tendency to cling is gradually exhausted.
The Four Great Vows of Mahāyāna Buddhism are: “However innumerable the Dharma gates, I vow to learn them all; however inexhaustible the afflictions, I vow to cut them all off; however boundless sentient beings are, I vow to liberate them all; however unsurpassed the Buddha Way, I vow to accomplish it.” We must arouse these Four Great Vows and constantly urge ourselves to practice with diligence and care, not merely for our own liberation. The Six Perfections and myriad practices are generosity, ethical discipline, patience, diligence, meditative concentration, and wisdom.
The first is generosity. Why should we practice generosity? In order to cut through miserliness and attachment. We are deeply attached and miserly, unwilling to give anything up. When we are willing to give, the capacity of the mind expands.
The second is ethical discipline. Here it means guarding the mind so that it does not stir. If the mind is constantly agitated and deluded thoughts arise in profusion, the practice cannot succeed.
The third is patience. It does not mean becoming angry and then forcibly suppressing the anger. No: doing so can cause illness through pent-up anger. What, then, should we do? We should contemplate emptiness. Nothing can be obtained, and even the “self” does not exist.
If there is no self, where can humiliation be found? If there is no self, who is there to be humiliated? Contemplate in this way, as the Diamond Sūtra teaches: “No mark of self, no mark of person, no mark of sentient being, and no mark of a life span.” If neither self nor person can be found, from where could humiliation arise? If there is no humiliation, what need is there to endure it? Patience that involves no enduring is great patience.
Nothing has independent existence; all forms are produced by causes and conditions. “Dharmas arising from causes and conditions, I declare, are emptiness.” Things do not exist in and of themselves but appear only when causes and conditions come together. We should therefore cease clinging to appearances. When we do not cling to appearances, the mind is empty; when the mind is empty, humiliation no longer exists.
The fourth is diligence. Practicing the Dharma and studying Buddhism both require diligence. How do we cultivate it? By tirelessly eliminating our deluded habits. This is why practitioners of the Pure Land school recite the Buddha's name tens of thousands of times a day: to sweep away deluded thinking and deluded thoughts. Our deluded thinking never stops, and our deluded thoughts take countless forms. They revolve in the mind all day without a moment's rest.
We notice them only when we sit down to recite the Buddha's name: one thought arises, then another. When we are busy, we do not see these thoughts and assume that they are absent. In fact, they never stop; we simply fail to notice them.
It is like a glass of muddy water. While the water is turbid, we cannot see the sediment. Only when the sediment settles and the water above becomes clear can we see it. Likewise, only as the deluded mind becomes quiet do we begin to see deluded thoughts moving incessantly. Seeing deluded thoughts during seated meditation or Buddha-recitation is therefore a good sign, because the mind is gradually becoming clearer.
Some people say, “It is bad that I see so many deluded thoughts when I meditate; I would be better off not meditating.” When they do not meditate, they do not see the thoughts and imagine that none exist. That is mistaken: the thoughts have never ceased. We must therefore practice with unremitting diligence—morning and evening, in displacement and adversity alike.
At every moment, observe the mind: as soon as a thought arises, see it and do not follow it. If we genuinely practice in this way without interruption, within three to five years we can break through and see our true nature. Why do some people practice for many years without success? Because thoughts continue to move at every moment; they have not kept watch over them and have not been diligent.
If they watch continuously, within three to five years the thoughts will certainly come to rest and body, mind, and world will dissolve into emptiness. By continuing to train amid situations and diligently eliminating habitual tendencies, they will eventually become fully integrated. This is certain. Practitioners of the Heart-of-Heart Dharma are therefore told to meditate constantly.
This does not mean meditating for two hours and then, on rising from the seat, letting the wild horses loose and allowing deluded thoughts to run unchecked. We must maintain continuous and seamless contemplation, watching deluded thoughts without following them. What does “meditation” strike at? It strikes at deluded thoughts: we see the point at which a thought arises and do not follow it. To “sit” is to see one's true nature. We must see it at every moment. This capacity follows us like a shadow and can never be separated from us.
Layman Fu said, “Night after night I sleep embracing the Buddha; morning after morning I rise together with him.” We sleep embracing the Buddha and rise with the Buddha because our true nature never leaves us. If we are truly willing to practice with unremitting diligence, I assure you that within three to five years you will attain realization.
But if the practice is intermittent—meditating when pleased and abandoning it when not—or
if one recites the Buddha's name or a mantra while the mind continues to wander, what use is it? When meditating, we must resolutely let go of everything, like a person utterly dead to worldly concerns, and continuously “recite with the mind and hear with the ears”. Only then is there an entry into the practice. Reciting with the mind is not reciting with the mouth; it is the thinking mind that does the reciting.
The ears must hear the sound of the mantra or the Buddha's name clearly and remain fixed upon it. Master Hanshan said, “When reciting the Buddha's name or a mantra, be like someone pushing a heavy cart uphill, exerting every effort to keep it moving.” It is a heavy cart going uphill, not a light cart rolling downhill. A light cart needs no effort; with a whoosh, it rolls down by itself.
But can a heavily loaded cart be pushed uphill without exertion? It cannot. Recitation must therefore be sustained with the same determined effort. Two hours of seated meditation alone do not count for much. After leaving the seat, we must remain observant at every moment and not follow thoughts as they arise. Practice in this way and within three to five years I guarantee that you will see your true nature. If you practice like this and do not succeed, come and blame me. These are not merely my words; the great patriarchs taught the same thing, and it has been verified in practice.
The fifth is meditative concentration. It is attained through unremitting diligence. Meditative concentration means remaining unconfused by circumstances and unwavering in mind. On seeing something pleasing, we do not become enamoured of it or let the mind surge with desire to obtain and possess it. On encountering something unpleasant or contrary to our wishes, we do not become afflicted.
When the mind is truly empty, it is constantly gathered in concentration and is no longer confused by events. Concentration does not mean sitting there rigid and motionless, still less being incapable of undertaking important tasks. We speak, work, and walk as usual; although engaged in every activity, the mind remains unmoved. It is like a mirror reflecting things.
Many images appear within it, yet the mirror itself does not move. It does not say, “This is good, so I want it; that is bad, so I reject it.” It makes no distinctions but simply reflects whatever appears.
If an object is long, a long image appears; if short, a short image; if square, a square image; if red, red; if blue, blue. The mirror neither grasps nor rejects and makes no discrimination. This is called the “object of direct perception”. The object of direct perception is our Original Face. Everyone practices in order to see their true nature and their Original Face.
Where is this precious nature, this Original Face? It is nowhere else; it shines directly before us. If, in an instant, we let go of everything, not a single thought arises, yet we are not insentient like wood or stone. Instead, there is lucid, vivid knowing.
This lucid awareness is everyone's Original Face. Having clearly seen this nature, we must protect the Original Face at every moment. Whether praised or slandered, the mind remains unmoved and pays no heed; in this way we safeguard the mind of direct perception. When this safeguarding has become mature and complete, there is no longer any need to guard it. Letting it respond freely to conditions, we accomplish the Great Way. The Buddhadharma is therefore not difficult to explain. If we are willing to practice, let go of everything, and continue tirelessly to work upon ourselves, we shall certainly attain realization.
The sixth is wisdom: the great wisdom that opens through meditative concentration. With it, we understand the causes and consequences of all things and the origin of the birth and death of sentient beings. Speaking of birth and death, we are originally unborn and undying; in truth, there is no birth or death. Why, then, do birth and death continually appear before us? Because the discriminating mind moves delusively.
If, when confronting circumstances, we neither give rise to thoughts nor pursue the objects before us, there is no birth and death. Birth and death are therefore illusory. Many people practicing Buddhism today cling to the idea that they must have somewhere to go at death and must know that destination in advance.
Yet if we have truly awakened to the Way, there is nowhere to go, because we have never died. We simply remain at ease in whatever circumstances arise, liberate beings in accordance with conditions, and roam freely in playful samādhi. What destination could be needed? Someone may say, “If you are awakened, you should know where you will go after death. That is called knowing your destination in advance. If you do not know it, you have not awakened.”
The statement sounds correct, but it requires careful examination. When one has truly awakened to the Way, Buddha-nature pervades empty space and the entire Dharma Realm. It neither moves nor wavers and has neither coming nor going. Every event is its manifestation; every place is its magical display. Where could one go? There is nowhere to go. If there were somewhere to go, would that not show that one had yet to awaken?
Later in this book, two kinds of attainment are discussed. The first occurs when a great light shines forth in the intermediate state at the moment of death. If we recognize that this light and the light radiated by the Buddha are one and the same, non-dual and without difference, and that this is our true nature, we are liberated on the spot and need not go anywhere.
In the second case, our capacity is limited: we dare not accept the recognition and do not realize that this is Buddha-nature, the very nature we share with all Buddhas. We may then be reborn in an eastern or western pure land to continue our practice. Because we have not awakened to the Way, there is still somewhere to go. Once we have truly awakened and attained realization, there is no need to go anywhere.
Nirvāṇa is explained in four ways. The first is nirvāṇa of intrinsic nature. Our Buddha-nature is originally unborn and undying: it does not arise when the body is born or perish when the body dies. The true nature of every sentient being is naturally so, originally beyond birth and death and enduring from beginningless time. This is called nirvāṇa of intrinsic nature.
The second is nirvāṇa with remainder, attained by practitioners of the Lesser Vehicle. They have brought only segmented birth and death to an end. Segmented birth and death means birth and death in the six realms, whereas transformational birth and death is the arising and ceasing of thoughts. Their view of dharmas has not been eliminated; something remains unresolved.
They still identify the elemental natures of earth, water, fire, and wind with a self. Their thoughts are not yet purified and transformational birth and death remains; hence it is called nirvāṇa with remainder. The third is the noble fruition realized by a Buddha, called nirvāṇa without remainder. Both attachment to a personal self and the view of a self in dharmas have been eliminated. Person and dharmas are both empty, and not the slightest thing can be obtained.
When both have been fully resolved and the two kinds of birth and death—transformational and segmented—have been relinquished, this is nirvāṇa without remainder. The fourth is non-abiding nirvāṇa. Having no abiding place means there is no particular place in which to dwell: there is nowhere it is not; it is everywhere.
When Śākyamuni Buddha was departing, he said, “I have not left you. I am always before you. Those whose eyes are pure can see me; those whose eyes are clouded cannot.” While afflictions and attachments remain, our vision is impure. If they are exhausted and deluded thoughts no longer arise, the pure Dharma-eye opens and we can see the Buddha everywhere. We should therefore not cling to a location or destination. Only then does great wisdom open. Great wisdom surging forth is expressed as the Six Perfections and myriad practices.
To attain Buddhahood, we must follow the Bodhisattva path, liberate sentient beings on a vast scale, and accumulate merit until the noble fruition is complete. Without complete merit and fully accomplished conduct, Buddhahood cannot be attained. To follow the Bodhisattva path is to liberate oneself and others and to awaken oneself and others. The Chinese term pusa (菩萨) abbreviates the transliteration of the Sanskrit bodhisattva and is explained in Chinese as “one who awakens sentient beings”.
We must awaken from and break through our own emotional views while enabling all sentient beings to awaken. We all have our personal biases; we respect and cherish our own parents and children, while ignoring and neglecting those of others. This is all down to the mischief of personal affection. Romantic attachment between men and women, in particular, is a root of birth and death.
Why do we have this body? Because of craving and desire: intense sexual desire gives rise to this mortal flesh. As long as such craving continues, birth and death continue. To “awaken sentient beings” is to awaken and liberate both oneself and others; this is the Bodhisattva path.
Merely entering the Bodhisattva path is not enough. One must practice over many aeons, advance to ever higher levels, and vow that all sentient beings will attain Buddhahood; only then can the fruition of Buddhahood be perfectly realized. Bodhisattvas pass through many levels: the Ten Faiths, Ten Abodes, Ten Practices, Ten Dedications, Ten Grounds, and so forth. Even a great Bodhisattva of the Tenth Ground remains one level below a Buddha.
To use an analogy, when liberating sentient beings, a Bodhisattva still entertains the perception of appearing in and withdrawing from the six realms, of entering one realm and leaving another. A Buddha, however, enters and leaves while never entering or leaving, and liberates sentient beings while liberating no sentient being. This slight distinction separates a Buddha from a great Bodhisattva. A Buddha is one whose awakening and conduct are perfect—that is, whose merit and wisdom are both complete. The Buddha is therefore also called the “Honored One Complete in Both”: the two completions are merit and wisdom. Awakening is great wisdom; conduct is the merit gained through liberating sentient beings. Only when awakening and conduct are both perfected can Buddhahood be attained.
A Buddha fully possesses the Three Bodies and Four Wisdoms. The Three Bodies are the Dharmakāya, Sambhogakāya, and Nirmāṇakāya. Our present practice is directed toward realizing the Dharmakāya: revealing our Original Face and seeing the Dharmakāya. Whether we practice in the Pure Land, Chan, or esoteric school, the aim is to realize and see the Dharmakāya.
How is the Sambhogakāya realized? Its realization is associated with differentiated wisdom, which is cultivated by liberating sentient beings and accumulating merit. Revealing our Original Face and seeing the Dharmakāya is fundamental wisdom, which recognizes reality at its root. Differentiated wisdom is gained through liberating sentient beings.
Sentient beings have different habits, just as some people prefer spicy food, some sweet, and some sour. Their capacities and aspirations differ, and so do the teachings they study: there are forms of meditation suited to ordinary beings, to the Lesser Vehicle, to Bodhisattvas, and to the Mahāyāna.
When liberating sentient beings, if we have mastered all these Dharma gates, we can respond to each person's capacity and circumstances with ease rather than being at odds with them. By forming wholesome affinities widely and doing every kind of good, we perfect our merit and thereby obtain the Sambhogakāya.
If we do nothing for sentient beings, where could our merit come from? To not benefit humanity, but only oneself, makes one a self-centered person who lacks merit. As the saying goes, “Offerings to Arhats are meagre.” One who seeks only personal liberation cannot attain Buddhahood. The Sambhogakāya is the fruition obtained after one has aroused the aspiration at the causal stage and perfected merit.
The Avataṃsaka Sūtra explains this clearly. When Sudhana saw the splendid and beautiful Sambhogakāya of Maitreya Bodhisattva—the Maitreya of Tuṣita Heaven—he marvelled at its majesty. Maitreya told him, “You have attained fundamental wisdom, but not differentiated wisdom; you do not yet possess the Sambhogakāya.
By liberating sentient beings, I perfected merit and thereby brought forth Maitreya's Tower and this luminous Sambhogakāya.” There are two kinds of Sambhogakāya: the body of self-enjoyment and the body of enjoyment for others.
The former is the vast body brought forth by majestic merit and virtue. The latter appears in order to inspire Bodhisattvas to practice at higher levels, and its size varies: a smaller Sambhogakāya appears to junior Bodhisattvas and a greater one to advanced Bodhisattvas. Seeing this luminous and magnificent Sambhogakāya arouses courage and diligence in them, inspiring them to practice still harder so that they too may realize it soon.
In a former life, Śākyamuni Buddha saw another Buddha whose magnificent form appeared while abiding in the Samādhi of Light, also called the Samādhi of Fire-Light. He greatly admired that Buddha and thought, “I too wish to possess such a Sambhogakāya.” Through vigorous, unremitting practice, he attained Buddhahood seven aeons earlier than he otherwise would have. The time required to attain Buddhahood is therefore not fixed.
We speak of attaining Buddhahood over three great incalculable aeons, but “incalculable” denotes a period whose measure cannot be known; its duration is not fixed and depends on how we practice. Vigorous diligence shortens the time, while indolence and procrastination lengthen it.
Venerable Ānanda is the clearest example. He and Śākyamuni Buddha first aroused the aspiration at the same time, yet by the time Śākyamuni had attained Buddhahood, Ānanda had still not awakened. The Śūraṅgama Sūtra was taught for Ānanda's sake.
Early or late attainment thus depends upon our diligence. Ānanda was foremost in learning. He delighted in hearing what one Buddha taught and what another taught; his knowledge was vast, but he did not apply himself to practice, and so it was insufficient. If we practice vigorously and diligently, the time becomes shorter.
To realize the Sambhogakāya and gain subsequently attained wisdom, we must liberate sentient beings. Otherwise, we attain only the fruition of Arhatship and not the Sambhogakāya.
The Nirmāṇakāya manifests freely and without obstruction in response to the capacities and conditions of sentient beings. As the Universal Gate Chapter of the Lotus Sūtra says: “For those who can be liberated by the body of a householder, such a body is manifested and the Dharma taught; for those who can be liberated by the body of an official, such a body is manifested and the Dharma taught.”
How is the Nirmāṇakāya realized? Practice must reach the point at which the subtle continuous stream is cut off. What is this subtle continuous stream? It is attention—manaskāra—one of the five universal mental factors taught by the Consciousness-Only school: attention, contact, feeling, perception, and volition.
This attention is the worst of all: it discriminates at every moment, discriminating about everything. And like a diver, it moves down in deep water, not on the surface, so it cannot be seen, and it moves extremely fast. Only when we finally reach Vajrasattva samādhi—the great samādhi—can this subtle continuous stream be severed.
We can then manifest hundreds of thousands of millions of transformation bodies to liberate hundreds of thousands of millions of sentient beings. Perfect Buddhahood requires the full realization of all Three Bodies. The Four Wisdoms arise through transforming the eight consciousnesses into wisdom. The ālaya consciousness (ālaya-vijñāna) becomes the Great Perfect Mirror Wisdom; the seventh, the Wisdom of Equality; the sixth, the Wisdom of Wondrous Observation; and the first five, the Wisdom of Accomplishing Activities.
This transformation proceeds in stages: “The sixth and seventh are transformed at the causal stage; the eighth and first five are perfected at fruition.” Our present work of eliminating habitual tendencies amid circumstances transforms the sixth and seventh consciousnesses. To transform the sixth is to change the discriminating mind into a mind that observes without discrimination.
From birth we habitually distinguish: this is good, that is bad; we want one and reject the other. Living all day amid judgements of self and other and right and wrong, deluded thoughts fly about and birth and death cannot end. The seventh is the transmitting consciousness. It resembles the porter at an institution, forwarding information from the first six consciousnesses to the eighth.
The eighth is the storehouse consciousness, like a warehouse that receives information from manas consciousness and stores it. It contains innumerable seeds accumulated over countless lives and aeons. Eliminating them all is extremely difficult; only a Bodhisattva of the Tenth Ground can exhaust them. We must therefore intensify our practice.
“Transforming the sixth and seventh at the causal stage” means that we must work upon them now, during practice, before the eighth and first five consciousnesses can be transformed and Buddhahood perfected. The eighth and the first five are transformed only later, at fruition, into the Great Perfect Mirror Wisdom and the Wisdom of Accomplishing Activities.
The ālaya consciousness (ālaya-vijñāna) of sentient beings is presently ignorant: it seizes and retains everything, good or bad. As the Great Perfect Mirror Wisdom, it simply reflects without moving or grasping. The first five consciousnesses—eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body—face outwards.
We often say, “Of eight brothers, one is foolish.” The foolish one is ālaya consciousness (ālaya-vijñāna), which accepts both good and bad without discrimination. “Five conduct business at the gate”—eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body engage external objects: the eye craves forms, the ear hears sounds, the nose smells odours, the tongue tastes flavours, and the body contacts objects.
“One comes and goes conveying messages”—the seventh receives information from the first six and conveys it to the eighth for storage. “One among them is the most astute”—the sixth consciousness has the greatest power. To attain Buddhahood, we must perfect the Three Bodies and Four Wisdoms. A single awakening is still far from Buddhahood; sustained, earnest practice remains essential.
The foundation of Buddhism is the Mahāyāna teaching, not the Hīnayāna. The Hīnayāna is directed toward one's own liberation, whereas the Mahāyāna is for everyone. “May sentient beings attain Buddhahood before I do” is the aspiration of a great-hearted Bodhisattva: may all of you attain Buddhahood first, and may I be the last. This is how we should arouse the aspiration.
People today do not think this way. Quite apart from Buddhahood, even when a small benefit is at stake they rush forward, crying, “Me first! Me first! I must be at the front of the queue.” This is the mind of an ordinary being. Those who study Buddhism must possess a vast capacity of mind; the greater it is, the sooner Buddhahood is attained. Only by arousing the great aspiration do we accord with the Buddhist spirit of serving the Dharma and humanity.
The principles discussed above are readily understood by Buddhists, but how is the problem of birth and death to be resolved? Where should Buddhist practice begin? Many practitioners remain at a loss. Some elderly people know only to recite the Buddha's name and burn incense, without understanding this question.
Others obtain a few experiences or indications through seated meditation and consult certain teachers, only to be told, “I'm sorry; I do not know and dare not speak irresponsibly.” Such a teacher has not practiced or developed any real attainment, so how could he know how birth and death are resolved? Buddhism in fact explains the matter clearly.
One approach is to transcend the Three Realms vertically—the Desire, Form, and Formless Realms—by practicing Chan or the esoteric teachings until habits of attachment and greed, anger, and ignorance are eliminated. The other is to transcend the Three Realms horizontally through the Pure Land teaching: reciting the Buddha's name and praying for the Buddha's compassionate reception and rebirth in the Western Pure Land of Ultimate Bliss.
Practitioners of Chan, Pure Land, and the esoteric teachings thus know where to begin. But what assurance do they have of attaining Buddhahood? Without deeply understanding the more profound Buddhist principles, they naturally do not know.
There is, however, a way to test one's assurance: verify the mind at two extremes. The first is the favorable extreme, when everything proceeds smoothly and accords with one's wishes. The second is the adverse extreme, when nothing goes as desired and one meets misfortune and failure everywhere.
In favorable circumstances, can the mind remain unmoved, neither becoming elated nor losing self-possession, with mindfulness of the Buddha still present? In adverse circumstances, can one remain free of unbearable grief and anger, with mindfulness of the Buddha still present? If both can be maintained, a practitioner of Buddha-recitation can be fully confident of rebirth in the Western Pure Land at death.
If favorable conditions make us so elated that we forget ourselves and cannot bring the Buddha's name to mind, or adverse conditions plunge us into such distress that we likewise cannot raise it, we have no assurance of rebirth there.
Someone may ask, “Surely that cannot be right. When the intermediate-state body emerges after death, will the Buddha not come to receive us? Does that not guarantee rebirth?” The Buddha does not lie or speak falsely and will certainly come to receive us.
But because we are confused by afflictions and attachments, like someone stupefied by strong wine, we may not see the Buddha when he comes. How, then, can we go with him? Master Lianchi therefore said, “Many recite the Buddha's name, but few are reborn in the West.” As an eminent Pure Land master, he would not lie to frighten people.
Why are many reciters but few who attain rebirth? Because their recitation lacks urgency and sincerity.
Their mouths recite the Buddha's name while their thoughts continue to race in every direction. We often see elderly people reciting while gossiping about one family and another. What effect can such recitation have? They are not single-mindedly mindful of the Buddha; their minds remain confused.
Śākyamuni Buddha therefore taught us to hold firmly to the Name for one day, two days, or as many as seven days, with one-pointed, undisturbed mind; then Amitābha Buddha appears before us.
If the mind is undisturbed, we see the Buddha before us. If it is in turmoil, we cannot see him even when he comes. Chan Master Yongming Yanshou explained: “The mind of one who recites the Buddha's name is like a basin of water, and the Buddha is like the moon in the sky.” When the water is clear, the moon appears within it.
When our mind is turbid like muddied water, the moon cannot appear and we cannot see the Buddha. The Buddha comes from nowhere and goes nowhere. The image that manifests in our mind is therefore called the Tathāgata, “Thus Come”.
When the pure karma of a Pure Land practitioner matures and rebirth approaches, an image of the Buddha manifests within the mind. We recite Amitābha Buddha, and the Buddha appears in the West in response; this is called the communion of stimulus and response. There are levels to the Buddha's manifestation in receiving sentient beings, because practitioners' attainment differs and so do the forms they see. Rebirth in the Western Pure Land is accordingly divided into nine grades. Those of the lower grades see only a Nirmāṇakāya Buddha; those of the middle grades see a Sambhogakāya Buddha; and only those of the highest grades see the Dharmakāya Buddha, the Buddha of the Land of Eternally Quiescent Light.
There are three kinds of actual realization in practicing the Dharma and transcending birth and death. The first is genuinely to refrain from following a thought when it arises. The thought dissolves immediately without the slightest delay, like drawing on water: as soon as a line is traced, the water closes and leaves neither shadow nor mark.
Like a bird crossing the open sky without leaving a track, we become free at the boundary of birth and death. We can go wherever we wish, no longer governed by karmic force; this is freedom in taking rebirth. The second is to remain entirely even-minded in the two kinds of circumstances described earlier, favorable and adverse, without the slightest movement of mind.
When the mind neither delights in what is pleasant nor becomes afflicted by what is unpleasant, segmented birth and death comes to an end. A Chan practitioner who has only just awakened has not yet ended segmented birth and death. Why not?
Because deeply rooted habits remain. The mind still follows circumstances and gives rise to emotion. In the doctrinal teachings, this is described as the persistence of the afflictions of thought; because they have not been eliminated, segmented birth and death has not ended. Pure Land practitioners therefore criticize Chan practitioners, saying that although they may have awakened, they have not ended segmented birth and death and are less secure than those following the Pure Land path. The reason is precisely that the afflictions of thought remain.
The doctrinal teachings divide coarse ignorance into afflictions of view and afflictions of thought. Afflictions of thought arise when the mind responds emotionally to objects. Afflictions of view concern understanding: once we recognize the right and wrong paths, truth and delusion, no longer go astray, and cease inverted attachment, the afflictions of view are cut off.
They are comparatively easy to eliminate; afflictions of thought are difficult. Habitually, people love what appears good and dislike or become afflicted by what appears bad. The mind remains unbalanced, moves delusively, and cannot relinquish its abiding attachments. Birth and death therefore cannot end, and one continues to cycle through the six realms. Accomplishing the first realization—not following thoughts as they arise—brings freedom in taking rebirth.
“Taking rebirth” means being master of one's own rebirth: one can go wherever one wishes, to the West or the East, without being entangled by karmic force. Accomplishing the second—not allowing the mind to be led by circumstances—brings freedom of transformation and liberation from birth and death.
The third realization is the cessation of the subtle continuous stream. Everything dissolves into emptiness and only the great wisdom of perfect enlightenment remains present. One can then manifest hundreds of thousands of millions of transformation bodies and liberate hundreds of thousands of millions of sentient beings. These are the genuine criteria by which practitioners verify realization of the Way. The Heart-of-Heart Dharma, like Chan, begins with the ālaya consciousness (ālaya-vijñāna) and applies practice directly to the mind-ground.
It differs in this respect from other esoteric teachings and is therefore called “Chan-Esoteric”: it breathes through the same nostril as Chan, although its initial method differs slightly. The Heart-of-Heart Dharma uses six mudrās and a mantra to reveal the original nature, after which the Chan method of sustaining the realization is used. Habitual tendencies are diligently eliminated; the mind is observed at every moment and awareness maintained everywhere, bringing the practice into accord with Chan.
Once observation has fully matured, one realizes stillness that is constantly aware and awareness that is constantly still. Having returned home and taken one's seat securely, there is no longer any need to maintain awareness or observation. This is the final assurance toward which all practice leads. Such practice is easy to describe, but actually accomplishing it still requires effort. Understanding the principle without realizing it in conduct is useless.
The path of practice therefore passes through four stages: the Dharma Realm of Phenomena, the Dharma Realm of Principle, the Dharma Realm of the Non-Obstruction of Principle and Phenomena, and the Dharma Realm of the Non-Obstruction of Phenomena and Phenomena. In the last of these, no phenomenon presents an obstruction and one can go anywhere without hindrance. One must then go a step further and not establish even the state of non-obstruction among phenomena. Only this is a true practitioner of Chan and one who has truly seen the mind and recognized one's true nature. This is the fundamental resolution of birth and death and the key to Buddhahood.